Retired man reviewing his investments on a laptop at home

Donating Appreciated Stock: Why Rochester Givers Skip the Check

Say you plan to give $10,000 to your church this year, and you also own a stock you bought years ago that has grown a lot. Donating appreciated stock instead of writing a check means you never pay capital gains tax on that growth, and it can lower your income tax this year. The charity gets the same $10,000 either way. The difference shows up on your return. It’s an idea we often bring into investment management conversations late in the year.

Why Donating Appreciated Stock Beats Writing a Check

Donating appreciated stock avoids ever having to pay capital gains tax on that growth. Compare that with selling the shares first. Selling would trigger the gain, and you’d donate what’s left after taxes. Giving the stock directly skips that step. The charity, as a tax-exempt organization, can sell the shares and keep the full amount. For a Rochester family that has owned the same shares for decades, the built-in growth can be large. Donating those shares turns that growth into a gift instead of a tax bill.

Lowering This Year’s Income Tax

Donating appreciated stock also helps lower your income tax in the current year. If you’ve held the shares for more than a year and you itemize, you can generally deduct their full market value. Picture a retired couple in Pittsford who donate shares they bought for $3,000 that are now worth $10,000. They avoid tax on the $7,000 gain and may deduct the full $10,000. For stock gifts, the deduction is generally limited to 30% of AGI. The SEC’s investor education site explains cost basis if you’d like a refresher.

Diversifying a Concentrated Position

Plenty of families hold a big share of their wealth in a single stock or fund. Selling to diversify can mean a large capital gains bill. So they hold on. Donating appreciated shares helps you diversify out of concentrated stock or fund holdings without incurring gains. You give part of the position to charity, then use the cash you’d have donated to buy a more balanced mix. Less of your portfolio rides on one holding.

Pairing Gifts With Roth Conversions

Donating appreciated stock is great to balance in years when Roth conversions occur. A Roth conversion moves money from a traditional IRA to a Roth IRA, and the converted amount counts as income that year. A stock gift in the same year can help bring down your AGI into lower tax brackets. We call this integrated planning: looking at giving, investing, and taxes together instead of one at a time. A thoughtful financial planning process is where these decisions come together.

If you’re weighing a Roth conversion this year, a quick discovery call can show how a stock gift might fit alongside it.

Check With the Charity First

Before you plan the gift, ensure the charity can receive stock. Not every organization is set up to accept shares. Call ahead. A small Monroe County nonprofit may need a different approach than a large national charity. Plan for timing, too: transfers can take several business days, and the gift generally counts when the shares reach the charity’s account. If a charity can’t take stock, a donor advised fund can, since DAFs are great for highly appreciated stock. FINRA’s investor resources explain how brokerage transfers work.

How to Get Started

Here’s a simple way to work through a year-end stock gift:

  1. Identify shares held more than a year with the largest gains.
  2. Confirm the charity can receive stock and get its transfer instructions.
  3. Check whether a Roth conversion is planned for the same year.
  4. Transfer the shares directly. Don’t sell them first.
  5. Keep the charity’s written acknowledgment, which is required for gifts of $250 or more.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: What if my stock has lost value? A: It’s usually better to sell it, claim the capital loss, and donate the cash. Donating losing shares directly wastes the loss.

Q: Do I have to itemize to benefit? A: To deduct the gift, yes. Even without itemizing, you still avoid capital gains tax on the shares you donate.

Give More of What You’ve Grown

Donating appreciated stock lets your investments support the causes you care about while trimming your tax bill. If you’d like a second set of eyes on your year-end giving, schedule a free, zero-obligation discovery call with O’Keefe Stevens Advisory through our contact page, and we’ll help you choose the right shares and timing.

Disclaimer

This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as personalized investment, tax, legal, insurance, or financial planning advice. The information presented is general in nature and may not be applicable to your individual circumstances. Health insurance options, ACA subsidy eligibility, tax consequences, and retirement planning strategies vary based on individual factors and are subject to change. Readers should consult with their tax advisor, insurance professional, attorney, or financial advisor before making any financial or healthcare-related decisions.

Advisory services offered through O’Keefe Stevens Advisory, an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities & Exchange Commission. Registration with the SEC does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

Tags

Comments are closed